This paper looks at immigration legislation introduced in the previous five Congresses (2015-2016 to 2023-2024) and concludes that, while interest in comprehensive immigration reform has waned, there have been a number of bills introduced on a bipartisan basis to fix specific problems in the immigration system. The greatest number of bills sought to ease restrictions on employment-based immigrant visas. While none of these have become law, the authors assert that demographic change and workforce shortages will continue to generate interest in legislative solutions. The authors provide data on legislation introduced to fix specific problems, including which problems were addressed, how many co-sponsors signed on and the balance between Democrat and Republican cosponsors, whether the legislation sought to ease or tighten immigration restrictions, and whether or not the legislation passed. Their data suggests that legislation that is narrowly-tailored to fix specific problems within the immigration system is more likely to gain bipartisan support and become law. There were a few successes during the analysis period, including bills pertaining to Special Immigrant Visas for Afghans who assisted U.S. forces in Afghanistan, a bill to fix issues with citizenship for certain adoptees, and legislation to fix other specific problems requiring minor tweaks to the immigration system. The authors suggest that even minor victories could have major impacts on the economy, and they remain hopeful that this model provides a path forward for bipartisan immigration reform in the current Congress. (Maurice Belanger, Maurice Belanger Associates)
Has Congress Given Up on Bipartisan Immigration Reform? A Data-Driven Look at Legislation Since 2015,
Bipartisan Policy Center, May 2025, 30 pp.
Authors: Theresa Cardinal Brown & Emerson Sprick